Spag, on July 7th, 2008 at 11:12 pm Said: Ben wins on the Wray stuff as expected. He has better sources than anyone except maybe Bledsoe and I suspect that is a tie at best, which is why I bet on Ben.
Jordan’s problem is that he clearly does have an agenda which lately seems to be more geared towards discrediting the Rhino in a form of ambush marketing. Of course, the Rhino has an agenda, too, but so far Jerry’s reporting has been nearly unassailable given the volume. This lawsuit will go nowhere because the facts simply aren’t there. Jordan’s agenda is less concerned about getting to the truth than it is challenging the Rhino series. He sees no cause to challenge the N&R reporting and they have been demonstrably wrong on a number of matters by any objective scale- source documents (often leaked by Ben) contradict the N&R’s version of events and corroborate Bledsoe.
I don’t know why Jordan feels compelled to take on the Rhino instead of City Hall. Certainly it is the latter with the credibility problem and what comes across is not Ben being jealous of Clarey and Jordan, but Jordan being jealous of Bledsoe.
In any case, I am not going to disparage Brian. He started a paper that has thus far survived where others have failed and that is worthy of respect. But YES! Weekly is not objective journalism anymore than the Rhino or the N&R. I just wish they would be more like the Rhino and admit it, and less like the N&R which pretends to be objective on key issues but isn’t. I don’t know why or how Wray became a Left/Right issue, but the appearance that YES! is giving is that they are one side simply because the Rhino is on the other. One more reason that I bet on Ben is that he strikes me overall as being Left of center, yet he is going against the grain on these GPD issues which enhances his credibility. He seems less concerned with politics and more concerned about being right, which may explain his beef with YES! Ben raised some serious issues about the YES! story that have not been refuted here or elsewhere.
Which leads back to Bledsoe. Question whether the reaction to Jerry’s series would be different if the series appeared in the N&R or YES! Weekly. At the end of the day, it comes down to Jerry’s credibility, not the publication that he is in, and nobody knows more about this story than Bledsoe. Bledsoe is the reason that the Rhino has become the authoritative account of this entire episode. So much has been written and so little of it refuted. Jordan can try as he wants to discredit Bledsoe, but that will be a very difficult task given Jerry’s track record and sourcing. Why this fight was chosen is a mystery to me.
The whole tenor of this story shifted to a City Manager out of control, incompetent and at odds with the actual facts as they started to trickle out, and a local paper (N&R) who sensationalized a story in terms of race that was refuted by objective facts a long time ago. Why in the fourth quarter YES! decided to resell the discredited story of Mitch Johnson and the N&R in light of all of the factual disclosures by Ben and Bledsoe makes no sense. A better story would be why did Mitch Johnson and the N&R get it so wrong?
One could easily claim that this assumes that Ben and Bledsoe are right, but I don’t see how that can be disputed when there is a document trail that supports their version of events and no document trail to support Mitch Johnson and the N&R. The mere fact that the City refuses to release the documents that they based their claim on is enough to cast doubt on their position, not to mention the inconsistencies documented by Ben and Bledsoe in those various documents when they were leaked.
The City Manager/N&R position is a loser. Why YES! wants to board that train defies common sense.